Some practical substance to go with this The opening post reads more like an advert than a discussion starter, so here is some actual detail that business owners tend to get wrong when the police, HMRC, Trading Standards or the HSE come knocking. A lot of it applies whether you trade as a sole trader, a partnership or through a Ltd company.
1. The police station interview - In England, Wales and Northern Ireland, anyone interviewed under caution is entitled to free and independent legal advice, regardless of income. This is not means tested. You can ask for the duty solicitor or name your own.
- A "voluntary interview" is still an interview under caution. People assume that because they were not arrested it is an informal chat. It is not. Everything said can be used in evidence.
- The caution in England, Wales and NI includes the words "it may harm your defence if you do not mention when questioned something which you later rely on in court". That means staying silent can count against you later. A solicitor will often advise either a prepared written statement or "no comment", depending on the disclosure the officers give beforehand. That judgment call is exactly why you want representation in the room.
- In Scotland the position is different. Since the Cadder ruling (now set out in the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 2016), suspects have the right to a solicitor before and during questioning, and the Scottish courts do not draw adverse inferences from silence in the way the courts south of the border do. Police station advice is arranged through the Solicitor Contact Line.
2. It is not just the police Most business owners who end up in a criminal process never see a police officer. The interview comes from:
- HMRC (tax fraud, VAT, PAYE, furlough and Bounce Back Loan abuse)
- Trading Standards (consumer protection, product safety, unfair trading)
- The Health and Safety Executive or the local authority (workplace injuries and deaths)
- The Environment Agency, SEPA or NRW (waste and pollution offences)
- The Insolvency Service (director conduct after a company failure)
These bodies must follow the same PACE Codes of Practice when interviewing under caution in England and Wales, and equivalent rules apply in Scotland and NI. The same advice applies: do not attend without a solicitor, and do not reply to an invitation letter in writing without advice either.
One HMRC point worth flagging: if you receive a letter under Code of Practice 9, that is HMRC telling you it suspects deliberate tax fraud but is offering a civil route (the Contractual Disclosure Facility) instead of prosecution. How you respond in the first 60 days matters enormously. Get a specialist tax adviser or solicitor involved before signing anything, because once you accept the offer you are committing to a full disclosure and the clock starts running.
3. Company and director: who is actually being investigated? - A Ltd company can be prosecuted in its own right, and so can its directors and officers personally under "consent, connivance or neglect" provisions found in most regulatory statutes. Ask the investigator in writing which it is. The answer affects whose solicitor should attend and whether interests conflict.
- Do not let the company's solicitor represent you personally without checking for a conflict. If the company's best defence is "the director acted alone", you need your own adviser.
- Sole traders and partners have no corporate shield at all, so the business records are personal records for these purposes.
4. Searches and documents If officers arrive with a warrant, ask to see it, note the scope, and get a receipt for everything taken. You can object to legally privileged material being seized. Do not delete emails or tidy up records once you know an investigation exists; that is a separate offence and far easier to prove than the original allegation.
Treat any invitation to interview as the moment to stop and pick up the phone to a solicitor, not after it.